Consulting Magazine - Best Practices Webinar
  • One on One

Kennedy Corner

  • »Breaking the Cycle of Volatility and Supply Chain Performance Deterioration

    The great moderation that lasted from the mid-1980s through 2007 was characterized by low volatility and strong gains in business performance that combined in the fashion of a virtuous cycle. The supply chain was a significant beneficiary and source of these gains.
  • »Disruption, Financial Services and the Buffalo Bills
    The year was 1996: Alanis Morissette and the Smashing Pumpkins dominated radio—we still listened to radio back then—while your Internet 1.0 experience began when your dial-up modem screeched for 20 seconds and then connected you to your AOL account. You had mail! It was in that year that Episode 7 of the fourth season of the popular SciFi drama The X-Files aired, during which a conspiracy was laid bare in a secret meeting by powerful men.
  • »It’s a Floorwax... It’s a Dessert Topping... Actually, it’s Both!
    There are few sure things in the world. One might cite death and taxes, but only slightly down the list is the inevitable answer a Big Four consultant provides to the question “What is your firm’s strength?” Everything, of course.
  • »Show Me The Money
    Management consulting is a cash business. Now salaries and bonuses within the consulting industry are certainly not at the stratospheric levels enjoyed by their kindred brethren in investment banking. But consultants generally do realize much-better-than-average wages relative to their counterparts in the corporate world.
  • »Will ‘Knowledge Workers’ (Consultants) Be Replaced by Machines? It’s Possible
    The management consulting industry to date has been largely unscathed by the wave of technological change. However, there are signs that digital technologies are now beginning to disrupt the management consulting industry as well, with potentially deep and far-reaching consequences.
  • »A Force in Consumer Banking
    Banks have been stepping up their customer satisfaction game in recent years against the typical market forces at play. The pace of change has been head-spinning for an industry not well known for its swift response to customers.
» View all

Travel Advisory

  • »Survey: Consultants Are On the Road Again
    After years of fits and starts in an uncertain economy, travel is back in the consulting profession, at least according to the results of our annual Best Places to Stay survey.
  • »Marriott Goes Big in NYC
    Marriott International, Inc. and G Holdings opened what they’re calling an “iconic addition” to the New York skyline, a combined 378-room Courtyard hotel and 261-suite Residence Inn hotel in midtown Manhattan. The $320 million, 68-story property is the tallest single-use hotel in North America.
  • »Best Places to Stay: Travel Bounces Back
    Consultants are on the road again, at least according to the results of our annual Best Places to Stay survey.
  • »FAA: ‘Staffing Challenges’ Causing Delays
    In case you haven’t noticed, non-weather related delays at U.S. airports are on the rise. (And I know you’ve noticed that weather-related delays are definitely on the rise.)
» View all

Book It!

  • »Q&A: Keeping It Simple
    BCG’s Six Simple Rules sets out to simplify some organizational complexity.
  • »Review: Leading the Life You Want
    It seems that everyone has an opinion on work/life balance these days, but Stewart D. Friedman’s Leading the Life You Want isn’t necessarily one of them.
  • »Review: The Culture Map
    Globalization led to the rapid connection of internationally based employees from all levels of multinational companies, and now those same employees are expected to collaborate with colleagues scattered all over the world.
  • »Review: Twitter is Not a Strategy
    Today’s digital frenzy has led many to declare that advertising is dead… or at least dying. Is it?
  • »Excerpt: Procurement as Productivity
    The following is an excerpt from the book Procurement 20/20: Supply Entrepreneurship in a Changing World by a quartet of McKinsey & Company consultants—Peter Spiller, Nicolas Reinecke, Drew Ungerman and Henrique Teixera.
  • »Review: The Risk-Driven Business Model
    Most companies focus their innovation on new products.
» View all

Security Check

New Image
  • Home
  • Rankings
  • Best Firms To Work For
9 12 2012
»2012: The Best Firms to Work For

The Best Firms to work for 2012After reviewing the results of our exclusive Best Firms to Work For survey, it appears consultants are working harder and longer hours, and our results show that it’s taking a toll on client service. But firms are fighting the good fight as culture and career development scores improve.

The most telling industry data, perhaps, to emerge from our Best Firms to Work For survey appears in the "survey averages" chart from 2009 through 2012. The  overall scores in each category the survey measures show where the profession is in relation to the last four years beginning with the “new normal” of 2009.

Looking at that chart, the most jarring drops occur in the Work/Life Balance and Client Engagement categories. Is it that consultants are working harder? Is it that people are never feel disconnected from the office or clients? More likely, as the economy rebounds and firms struggle to find the talent to keep up with demand, employees are left with very little downtime, jumping from one engagement to the next. And it’s having an impact on the Client Engagement scores. Seems likely.

On the positive side, firm culture remains strong, likely because consultant job satisfaction tends to rise as consultants are engaged in stimulating work in dynamic industries. Several industries—healthcare, financial services, public sector, energy, retail and manufacturing—fit the bill. Plus, firms are doing well. There’s nothing like a positive bottom line, (and bonuses that come with it) to help morale. And culture will remain high as long as consultants see investment in them, and the Career Development numbers would indicate that’s happening across the industry.

From an individual firm perspective, what else can we say about Bain & Company. The firm simply amazes each year and it’s now 10 consecutive years as the No. 1 firm. And Stroud Consulting is putting an impressive run of its own together—three years in a row and four out of five—as the top firm in the Best Small Firms to Work For survey. 

Meanwhile, five firms—CapTech, Carlisle & Gallagher, Loft9, Aspen Advisors and Strong-Bridge make their Best Firms debut.

What Makes a Best Firm?
2012 Survey AveragesTo be named a Best Firm to Work For firms were ranked in six categories. Each measures a different aspect of employee satisfaction. The following describes the issues at play within each category. The criteria used for Best Small Firms is identical, but it measures firms between 20 and 250 consultants.

Client Engagement
This category reflects the quality of work consultants perceive their firm is doing. It is not a measure of the actual work being done, but the more valuable a firm’s consultants perceives their work to be, the more engaged they tend to be in their client’s—and firm’s—success.

Firm Culture
Firm culture reflects the shared values, standards, ethics, and goals of a firm. Gone are the days when firms would hire a generation of future partners from a leading campus and hone their skills and ethos over the course of a career. Today’s firms are comprised of talent that has spent years at other firms, and in other industries. Building and sustaining a strong culture, despite the lack of homogony in background and life experiences, becomes all the more difficult.

Firm Leadership
Economic uncertainty tests leadership in big ways. The economy of the last several years certainly tested their decision-making and internal communication skills. In 2012, leadership had to chart a new course and generate confidence in the firm’s direction. The more confidence the rank and file consultants have in their leaders, the more apt they are to be happy at their firm. But the opposite is also true.

Career Development
The campus pipeline is just starting to be refilled this year, which will force some promotions up through the higher staffing levels. However, setting and communicating those goals is a challenge. Handling it well can make consultants want to stay with your firm longer; doing it poorly can encourage defections.

Work/Life Balance
This category reflects how well consultants perceive their firm as enabling them to balance their life outside of their day job. Given the heavy work and travel regiment required, this is a difficult task. But understanding which firms handle this challenge can go a long way to identifying true employers of choice.

Compensation & Benefits
This category reflects consultants’ satisfaction with their compensation and non-cash benefits and does not necessarily reflect which firms pay the most. The happier consultants are with their job, the more they’re willing to settle for making less. Such is the case with consultants from smaller firms who continue to report higher satisfaction despite smaller paychecks. But when consultants are unhappy, this category tends to be the easy scapegoat for their frustrations.

Who Took the Survey?
Who Took the Survey?The Best Firms to Work For rankings are based on an online survey conducted in the summer of 2012. Nearly 13,000 consultants participated, representing more than 400 firms. The consultants operate in every service line, across at least 32 different project/practice areas, and serve clients across all major industries. About three-quarters of the respondents came from the United States. Consultants at every staff level participated. Here is the breakdown of participation, by staff level.
The Best Firms to Work For 2012
1. Bain & Company 9. PwC
2. The Boston Consulting Group 10. Kurt Salmon
3. North Highland 11. Booz Allen Hamilton
4. Slalom Consulting 12. MorganFranklin
5. CapTech 13. Capco
6. Deloitte Consulting 14. A.T. Kearney
7. Huron Consulting Group 15. West Monroe Partners
8. Carlisle & Gallagher Consulting Group  
The Best Small Firms to Work For 2012
1. Stroud Consulting 9. Aspen Advisors
2. Fitzgerland Analytics 10. PeopleFirm
3. Vynamic 11. Caiman Consulting
4. Cask 12. Strong-Bridge
5. Systems Evolutions, Inc. 13. Acquis Consulting Group
6. Meridian Compensation Partners 14. Cumberland Consulting
7. Impact Advisors 15. Infinitive
8. Loft 9  
»Related Articles
  • Best Firms To Work For
  • Rankings
  • Platinum Sponsors:


    Gold Sponsors:


    Ernst & Young

    Silver Sponsors:


    Alix Partners

  • Register

    Gold Sponsors:

    Ernst & Young

    Silver Sponsors:

  • Featured Speakers:

    Joseph Kornik

    Joseph Kornik
    Publisher and Editor-in-Chief,
    Consulting magazine

    Brian Murphy

    Brian Murphy
    Chief of Staff, Point B

    Brian Jacobsen

    Brian Jacobsen
    General Manager, Slalom Consulting

    Tom Rodenhauser

    Tom Rodenhauser
    Managing Director, Advisory Services, Kennedy Consulting Research & Advisory

    Sponsor Speaker:

    Drew West

    Drew West
    Director, Product Marketing,

    Sponsored By:

    Deltek Logo


page loading